Medi-Cal Fraud Allegations Under California Criminal Law (Penal Code 550)
Medi-Cal is California's state-administered healthcare program that provides medical benefits to low-income individuals, seniors, and people with disabilities.
Because billions of dollars are distributed annually through this program, California prosecutors and insurance fraud units aggressively pursue fraud investigations.
Medi-Cal fraud is most commonly charged under California Penal Code 550.
It can be prosecuted as either a misdemeanor or a felony and may result in a defendant being sentenced to jail or prison, ordered to pay restitution, and subject to substantial fines and professional licensing consequences.
If you are under investigation or have been charged with Medi-Cal fraud, early legal intervention is critical.
Your best chance of a positive outcome in a healthcare fraud case is with a California criminal defense attorney at Cron, Israels & Stark. To schedule a consultation, call (424) 372-3112 or use the contact form here.
What Is Medi-Cal Fraud?
Medi-Cal fraud involves knowingly submitting false, misleading, or fraudulent information to obtain reimbursement or benefits from the Medi-Cal program.
Penal Code 550 makes it illegal to:
-
Present a false or fraudulent claim for payment
-
Submit false documentation to increase reimbursement
-
Bill for services not provided
-
Engage in schemes to defraud an insurance program
-
Obtain benefits through false eligibility statements
Both healthcare providers and patients can face charges.
Common Types of Medi-Cal Fraud Allegations
Billing for Services Not Performed
One of the most common allegations is submitting claims for procedures or services that were never actually delivered.
Example:
A clinic submits reimbursement claims for cancelled patient visits. If Medi-Cal pays those claims, prosecutors may allege intentional fraud.
Upcoding and Unnecessary Procedures
“Upcoding” occurs when a provider performs a basic procedure but bills for a more complex and expensive service.
Fraud allegations may involve:
-
Exaggerated diagnostic codes
-
Misrepresented treatment levels
-
Billing for medically unnecessary procedures
False Eligibility Claims
Patients may face charges for:
-
Concealing income
-
Falsifying residency information
-
Using another person's benefits
-
Submitting claims for unused services
Kickbacks and Referral Schemes
Healthcare providers may be charged if they:
-
Offer or receive payments for patient referrals
-
Participate in coordinated billing schemes
-
Exchange compensation for purchasing medical goods or services
These allegations often arise in broader healthcare fraud investigations.
Intent to Defraud Is Required
Medi-Cal fraud is not based on negligence or clerical error.
To convict under Penal Code 550, prosecutors must prove:
-
You knowingly made a false statement or claim
-
The statement involved a material fact
-
You intended to deceive Medi-Cal
-
The deception resulted in financial benefit
Intent to defraud is often the most contested element in these cases.
Mistakes in bookkeeping, coding errors, or administrative confusion do not automatically constitute criminal fraud.
How Prosecutors Investigate Medi-Cal Fraud
Medi-Cal fraud investigations often involve:
-
Billing audits
-
Review of patient records
-
Interviews with patients and staff
-
Undercover operations
-
Financial forensic analysis
-
Coordination with insurance fraud units
These cases can be document-intensive and highly technical.
Penalties for Medi-Cal Fraud in California
Penal Code 550 is a “wobbler,” meaning it can be filed as either a misdemeanor or felony.
Misdemeanor Medi-Cal Fraud
If the alleged loss is $950 or less, penalties may include:
-
Up to 6 months in county jail
-
A fine up to $1,000
-
Informal probation
-
Restitution
If reduced from a felony, jail exposure may increase to up to 1 year.
Felony Medi-Cal Fraud
If the alleged loss exceeds $950, penalties may include:
-
2, 3, or 5 years in state prison
-
A fine of up to $10,000
-
Restitution
-
Professional license consequences
Loss amount calculations can significantly affect sentencing exposure.
Related Charges Often Filed with Penal Code 550
Medi-Cal fraud cases frequently include additional charges such as:
-
Welfare and Institutions Code 14014
-
Welfare and Institutions Code 14107
-
Welfare and Institutions Code 14107.2
-
Penal Code 470 (Forgery)
Multiple counts increase potential sentencing and restitution exposure.
Defenses to Medi-Cal Fraud Charges
Lack of Intent
The most common defense is that there was no intent to defraud.
Possible arguments include:
-
Administrative error
-
Coding misunderstanding
-
Staff miscommunication
-
Disputed medical necessity
-
Inaccurate government loss calculation
Without proof of intentional deception, prosecutors cannot obtain a conviction.
Insufficient Evidence
These cases often rely on complex billing analysis. A defense attorney may challenge:
-
Accuracy of audit findings
-
Reliability of patient interviews
-
Interpretation of medical codes
-
Calculation of financial loss
-
Connection between the defendant and the alleged conduct
Negotiated Resolutions
In some cases, defense counsel may:
-
Negotiate misdemeanor reductions
-
Argue for civil resolution instead of criminal prosecution
-
Minimize restitution and custody exposure
Early negotiation can significantly improve outcomes.
Frequently Asked Questions About Medi-Cal Fraud
What is Medi-Cal fraud under Penal Code 550?
It is the intentional submission of false or fraudulent claims to obtain reimbursement or benefits from California's Medi-Cal program.
Is Medi-Cal fraud always a felony?
No. It is a wobbler. If the alleged loss is under $950, it may be charged as a misdemeanor.
What must the government prove?
Prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you knowingly made a false statement about a material fact with the intent to defraud Medi-Cal.
Can billing mistakes result in criminal charges?
Simple billing errors or negligent bookkeeping do not automatically constitute fraud. Intent to defraud must be proven.
Can healthcare providers lose their professional license?
Yes. A conviction may trigger disciplinary action by professional licensing boards, including suspension or revocation.
Can felony Medi-Cal fraud be reduced to a misdemeanor?
In some cases, yes. Reductions may occur through plea negotiations, depending on the strength of the evidence and the loss amount.
Why You Need an Experienced California Criminal Defense Lawyer
Medi-Cal fraud allegations can carry serious criminal penalties and professional consequences. Healthcare providers may face incarceration, heavy restitution, reputational harm, and licensing discipline.
These cases are often complex and technical. An experienced California criminal defense attorney can:
-
Challenge proof of intent
-
Dispute financial loss calculations
-
Identify weaknesses in billing audits
-
File motions to suppress improperly obtained evidence
-
Negotiate favorable resolutions when appropriate
Early representation can significantly influence the direction of a Medi-Cal fraud case.
The Los Angeles-based criminal defense attorneys at Cron, Israels & Stark are here to help. Schedule your consultation today.
Related Content: