Contact Us Today (424) 372-3112

DA Reject

DA Reject in California: What It Means and What Happens Next

Learning that your case has been DA-rejected in California brings immediate relief, but it can also create confusion about your legal status and record.

A district attorney's decision not to file charges is a highly favorable outcome, yet it does not always mean the situation is permanently resolved. Many people mistakenly assume a DA reject closes the matter forever.

In reality, the arrest may still appear in law enforcement databases and public background checks, and prosecutors may revisit the matter if new evidence emerges.

Understanding what a DA reject means, why prosecutors reject cases, and how to permanently protect your record under California law is essential for your peace of mind.

What Is a DA Reject in California Criminal Law?

A DA reject occurs when a California prosecutor reviews a case submitted by law enforcement following an arrest and formally decides not to file criminal charges.

After police complete an investigation and make an arrest, they submit their police report and evidence package to the local District Attorney's Office. The prosecutor evaluates the case and chooses one of three primary options:

  • File formal criminal charges against the arrestee.

  • Reject the case outright because of a lack of evidence or legal defects.

  • Request further investigation from law enforcement before making a final filing decision.

A DA reject indicates that the prosecution's case does not meet the legal or evidentiary standards required to initiate formal court proceedings at that time. While a DA reject is not a judicial finding of factual innocence, it is a critical victory because no court case opens and no criminal charges enter the court record.

Why Do Prosecutors Reject Cases in California?

District attorneys in California decline to file criminal charges for various factual, evidentiary, and procedural reasons. Prosecutors must believe they can prove a case beyond a reasonable doubt in court before filing:

Reason for DA Reject

Real-World Scenario

Prosecution Impact

Insufficient Evidence Police arrest a suspect based on suspicion, but find no stolen property or video footage. The case is rejected because the prosecution failed to meet the burden of proof.
Lack of Probable Cause Officers conduct an unlawful traffic stop without reasonable suspicion and discover contraband. Charges cannot be filed because evidence is legally tainted.
Witness Unavailability A complaining witness in a domestic dispute recants their statement and refuses to testify. Prosecution lacks key testimony to prove essential elements.
Credibility Issues Eyewitnesses offer conflicting descriptions of a suspect's appearance and actions. Severe doubt undermines the prosecution's ability to win at trial.
Constitutional Violations Officers conduct an illegal search or interrogate a suspect without giving Miranda warnings. Key evidence gets excluded, leaving prosecutors with an unprovable case.
Insufficient Proof of Intent An individual accidentally takes someone else's property during a miscommunication. The essential legal element of intent (mens rea) is missing.
Mistaken Identity A suspect is detained based on a vague physical description that does not match digital records. Creates reasonable doubt, requiring immediate rejection.
Further Investigation Needed A DUI arrest is made, but chemical blood test results are pending lab analysis. Prosecutors issue a temporary reject pending lab reports.
 

Is a DA Reject the Same as a Dismissal?

No, a DA reject is not the same as a court dismissal. The main difference is when the decision occurs and whether court charges were ever filed.

Legal Dimension DA Reject Court Dismissal
Timing Occurs before formal criminal charges are filed in court. Occurs after formal criminal charges have been filed.
Court Involvement No court case is ever opened or scheduled on a court docket. A criminal court case exists and a judge handles it.
Record Impact Generates an arrest record, but no court case record exists. Creates both an arrest record and an official court case record.
Authority Decided entirely by the District Attorney's Office. A judge orders it, or prosecutors request it in open court.

Can Charges Be Filed Later After a DA Reject?

Yes, prosecutors can file charges later following a DA reject under specific circumstances.

Because prosecutors never filed formal charges, double jeopardy does not apply to a DA reject. Prosecutors can refile charges if:

  • Law enforcement discovers new physical evidence or forensic proof.

  • New witnesses step forward, or key witnesses become available to testify.

  • The original rejection was marked as a "reject for further investigation" pending lab reports (such as DNA, blood alcohol, or narcotics analysis).

California's statute of limitations governs the prosecution's window to refile charges.

For most misdemeanors, prosecutors generally have one year from the date of the alleged offense to file. For felonies, the statute of limitations is typically three years or longer, depending on the crime's severity.

What Happens to Your Record After a DA Rejects Your Case?

Even when a District Attorney rejects your case, your arrest record does not automatically disappear.

When law enforcement makes an arrest, an entry is created in state and federal law enforcement databases (such as the California Department of Justice and the FBI). Unsealed arrest records can still surface on standard background checks run by prospective employers, landlords, and licensing boards.

To ensure an uncharged arrest does not harm your personal or professional future, you must take active record-clearing measures under California law.

How Do Related California Laws Help Clear Your Record?

Understanding how a DA reject interacts with specific sections of the California Penal Code helps you determine the best path to protect your clean record.

  • California Penal Code 849 PC (Release Without Charges): Applies when an individual is arrested but released without formal charges because of insufficient evidence. Under PC 849(b), the arrest can be reclassified as a detention only, ensuring it is not classified as a formal criminal arrest on state records.

  • California Penal Code 851.8 PC (Petition for Factual Innocence): The strongest record-clearing remedy available after a DA rejects it. If a judge grants a PC 851.8 petition, the court orders your arrest record sealed and destroyed. Once granted, you can legally state on job and housing applications that you were never arrested for the incident.

  • California Penal Code 851.87 PC (Sealing Arrest Records as a Matter of Right): Under Senate Bill 393, if a DA reject occurs and the statute of limitations has expired (or refiling is no longer possible), you are entitled to have your arrest record sealed as a matter of right, preventing it from being viewed by private employers.

  • California Penal Code 1385 PC (Court Dismissal): Governs judicial dismissals after charges are filed in court. Unlike a DA reject, PC 1385 requires a judge to dismiss charges in the furtherance of justice.

  • California Penal Code 1538.5 PC (Motion to Suppress Evidence): Challenges evidence seized during illegal searches or warrantless detentions. Suppression of key evidence under PC 1538.5 is a common reason prosecutors must issue a DA reject or drop pending charges.

What Steps Should You Take Immediately After a DA Reject?

  1. Obtain Official Confirmation: Secure written verification from the court or District Attorney's Office confirming that no charges were filed and the case was formally rejected.

  2. Consult a California Criminal Defense Attorney: Work with a lawyer to review whether the rejection is final or marked "pending further investigation."

  3. Petition to Seal and Destroy Your Arrest Record: File a petition under California Penal Code 851.8 or 851.87 to ensure the arrest entry is removed from public background databases.

  4. Avoid Public Discussion: Do not post details about the incident, your arrest, or the DA reject on social media while the statute of limitations remains open.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is a DA reject considered a good outcome?

Yes. A DA reject means the District Attorney evaluated the police reports and decided not to file formal criminal charges against you. It avoids court appearances, bail requirements, public court filings, and potential conviction penalties.

Will a DA reject show up on background checks?

Yes, unless you take legal steps to seal it. While a DA reject shows that no criminal charges were filed, the initial arrest entry remains in law enforcement databases and may surface on employer or housing background checks until sealed under California Penal Code 851.8 or 851.87.

Can the District Attorney change their mind and file charges later?

Yes. Because formal charges were not filed in court, double jeopardy does not attach. If the case was rejected pending further investigation or if new evidence surfaces within the statute of limitations, prosecutors can file charges at a later date.

What is the primary difference between a DA reject and an expungement?

A DA reject occurs before charges are ever filed, meaning there is no conviction. An expungement under California Penal Code 1203.4 applies to individuals who were charged and convicted of a crime, allowing them to withdraw a guilty plea and have the conviction dismissed after completing probation.

How long does the prosecutor have to refile charges after a DA rejects?

The timeframe is governed by the statute of limitations for the specific offense. In California, prosecutors generally have one year for most misdemeanor allegations and three or more years for felony allegations.

How can I get an arrest record sealed and destroyed after a DA reject?

You can file a Petition for Factual Innocence under California Penal Code 851.8 or petition to seal your arrest record under Penal Code 851.87. If the court approves it, law enforcement agencies must seal and destroy all records, police reports, and booking photos associated with the arrest.

How We Can Help You

While receiving a DA reject is a major legal victory, leaving your arrest record unmanaged can still create unexpected hurdles for your career, housing, and reputation. To prevent prosecutors from refiling charges and secure a clean record, you need proactive legal action.

The experienced California criminal defense attorneys at Cron, Israels & Stark can help you navigate the aftermath of a DA reject by:

  • Verifying Case Status: Confirming with local prosecutors whether your case is completely closed or marked for further investigation.

  • Protecting Against Refiling: Managing communications with police and District Attorney investigators to defend your rights if law enforcement attempts to reopen the matter.

  • Clearing Your Record: Preparing and filing petitions under California Penal Code 851.8 and 851.87 to seal and destroy your arrest records permanently.

Take the necessary steps to secure your peace of mind and protect your record. Contact Cron, Israels & Stark today at (424) 372-3112 or fill out our online contact form to schedule a confidential consultation with an experienced defense lawyer.

Related Legal Topics

Contact Us Today

Cron, Israels & Stark is committed to answering your questions about All Misdemeanor and Felony Crime law issues in Santa Monica and Los Angeles, California.

We offer a free consultation and we'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

Menu