Most sexual crimes are prosecuted in state courts under California's Penal Code. However, some sex crimes fall under federal jurisdiction based on the circumstances, such as crosses state lines, occurring on federal property, or violating federal laws.
For example, trafficking minors across state lines for sexual exploitation or crimes involving child pornography distributed across state borders are typically considered federal offenses. There are also key federal laws, such as the Mann Act and the Adam Walsh Act, that are crucial in determining if a sex crime becomes a federal offense.
The Mann Act criminalizes the transportation of people across state lines for illegal sexual activities. While initially focused on human trafficking, this law has evolved to target broader sexual exploitation crimes, including child trafficking and prostitution. Simply put, any case involving transportation for sex across state or national borders, including coercion and exploitation, will often result in federal criminal charges.
The Adam Walsh Act focuses on child protection and offender registration. This law enhances federal jurisdiction in cases involving child pornography, sexual exploitation, and abuse. An important element of this law is the establishment of a national sex offender registry, mandating that offenders convicted of specific federal sex crimes register, often for life.
The Adam Walsh Act also created harsher penalties for child pornography and exploitation offenses that occur across state lines or involve the internet.
Additionally, certain criminal acts will automatically qualify as federal sex offenses, such as human trafficking. Under the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, trafficking minors for sexual purposes is a federal crime if it involves crossing state or international borders.
Crimes involving the production, distribution, or possession of child pornography that crosses state lines or appears on the internet also fall under federal jurisdiction. This includes obscene materials exchanged via digital platforms that operate across multiple states.
If a sexual assault occurs on federal property, such as military bases, national parks, or federal buildings, the crime is automatically handled by federal courts. Internet-related sex crimes that cross state boundaries for online platforms for child exploitation, solicitation, or trafficking frequently result in federal involvement. All of these offenses carry harsh consequences due to the federal government's interest in addressing interstate crime.
Sex Offenses - Quick Facts
- Many sex crimes under California state law are simultaneously violations of federal law.
- When there is an overlap between federal and state law, the federal government often defers to states.
- There are certain circumstances in sex crimes where federal law takes precedence and prosecutes.
- People accused of federal sex crimes may face more severe penalties than those at the state level.
- A California sex crime can become a federal crime when crossing state lines or occurring on federal property.
- Federal property can include a military base, national park, or federal building.
- A state sex crime also becomes a federal crime when the crime directly affects federal institutions, such as a prison.
- A sex crime often becomes a federal sex offense when it involves the internet (online).
- Federal sex crimes include trafficking minors across state lines for sexual exploitation.
- Child pornography distributed across state borders is also considered a federal crime..
When Does Federal Law Take Precedence?
Federal law governs sex offenses that involve particular conditions or circumstances beyond the scope of state authority. For a California sex crime to be prosecuted as a federal offense, specific conditions must apply. As noted, these include crossing state lines, use of federal infrastructure, crimes on federal property, and offenses against federal employees. Let's review each below:
- Crossing State Lines. Sex offenses involving interstate activities fall under federal jurisdiction. For instance, if someone crosses state lines to engage in illegal sexual activity, it becomes a federal offense. It also involves victims who are transported across state lines.
- Use of Federal Infrastructure. The use of any federal infrastructure (internet, mail, or phone systems) related to a sex crime often leads to federal charges. This is because many crimes, such as the production, possession, or distribution of illegal materials (child porn), involve digital communication or mailing systems, placing them within federal jurisdiction. The use of these federal systems can significantly impact the jurisdiction of a case, often leading to federal charges.
- Crimes on Federal Property. Sex crimes that occur on federal property are prosecuted under federal law, such as offenses in national parks, military bases, federal prisons, or other federally owned buildings. State governments have no authority over actions occurring on federally controlled land.
- Offenses Against Federal Employees. Sex crimes committed against federal employees, such as military personnel or federal law enforcement agents, could result in federal charges. These cases are handled in federal courts. When any of these factors occur, the federal government has a rationale for involvement, and people accused of such sex offenses face an enhanced level of prosecution.
Federal Sex Offenses
Certain types of sex crimes are often prosecuted at the federal level, even though they often overlap with California law. These types of offenses include child pornography, sex trafficking, and online exploitation. Let's review each below:
- Child Pornography. Federal authorities will often pursue cases involving the possession, production, or distribution of child pornography. The use of the internet and online storage makes these crimes inherently cross-state and national boundaries. Federal law imposes mandatory minimum sentences for these offenses, reflecting the strictness and seriousness of federal law and the weight of federal involvement in such cases.
- Sex Trafficking. Human trafficking is a primary target of federal law enforcement, such as cases involving minors transported across state or international borders are prosecuted under federal statutes. Federal agencies such as the FBI and Homeland Security are typically involved..
- Online Exploitation. Federal law enforcement has strict guidelines and dedicated task forces to address crimes involving the exploitation of minors in sexual activities online or the disseminating of exploitative materials. This thorough approach, designed to protect vulnerable individuals, often triggers federal involvement in such cases.
Penalties for Federal Sex Crimes
Federal sentences, imposed within the United States Sentencing Guidelines, are notably severe, often exceeding those imposed in California state courts.
The requirement for sex offender registration, a form of punishment that can be even harsher than prison time, is usually part of the sentence, underscoring the gravity of federal sex crimes and the serious consequences individuals face when convicted.
Under the Sex Offender Registration and Notification Act (SORNA), the requirements for sex offender registration have become more severe. Prior to being released from federal custody, prisoners are told that they must register themselves in the National Sex Offender Registration and Notification System and update their status whenever their address changes.
Sex offenders are required to provide information such as their residence, school attendance, and employment status. Depending on the severity of the federal sex offense, they may need to stay registered as a sex offender for different amounts of time, such as:
- Tier I Offenders - 15 years.
- Tier II Offenders - 25 years.
- Tier III Offenders - lifetime registration.
Some of the most common federal sex crimes and their penalties include up to life in federal prison and a harsh fine for child pornography. Up to 15 years in federal prison and fines for sexual abuse of a minor, and up to life in federal prison for aggravated sex abuse.
Defenses for Federal Sex Offenses
The difference between state and federal prosecution can have harsh implications for anyone accused of a sex crime. Federal penalties include longer sentences and harsher conditions than those imposed under California law. Thus, if you are accused of federal sex crimes, you need to act accordingly..
A federal criminal defense attorney who is experienced in both California state law and federal law can be instrumental in such cases. In circumstances where a sex crime could be tried either at the federal or state level, defense lawyers with federal experience may negotiate to have charges filed at the state level.
This is crucial because, with less severe penalties, you might have greater opportunities for alternative sentencing options, such as rehabilitation programs or reduced charges.
To achieve this, we can argue that the crime lacks sufficient federal factors, such as no crossing of state lines or use of federal infrastructure. Our defense attorneys will also work to reduce charges and penalties by demonstrating mitigating factors, challenging key pieces of evidence, or negotiating plea agreements. For additional information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Cron, Israels & Stark, located in Los Angeles, California.
Related Content:
