Return fraud in California is a serious offense that occurs when someone knowingly deceives a retailer to obtain money, merchandise, or services through fraudulent return transactions.
Simply put, it involves deliberately misrepresenting facts about a product's purchase history, condition, or ownership to secure an unauthorized refund, exchange, or store credit. It's considered a type of theft crime.
Penal Code 484(a) PC defines theft as intentionally and unlawfully taking property that does not belong to you with the intent to deprive the true property owner of the use and enjoyment of that property.
Theft can manifest in numerous forms, including return fraud. Theft by fraud occurs when false pretenses or deceit are used to acquire property that does not belong to you.
Returning stolen or purchased property in exchange for cash or store credit can lead to criminal charges for theft.
Return fraud can result in severe consequences. Petty theft, shoplifting, and grand theft are all potential charges, each carrying serious legal repercussions under the California Penal Code.
Examples of Return Fraud
- Price switching involves changing price tags or labels.
- Repackaging items in less expensive packages or boxes.
- Returning an item to a store that you have stolen, or knew was stolen, in exchange for cash or credit.
- Forging a receipt to show that you purchased an item that you have stolen.
- Picking up a product off the shelf and immediately returning the item to customer service.
- Using stolen credit cards or bad checks to obtain merchandise to return or resell.
- Employee fraud involves working with a store employee to steal or return merchandise.
Retailers are employing increasingly sophisticated methods to prevent the losses they suffer each year due to return fraud. These methods include facial recognition software that monitors customer activity, video camera monitoring and surveillance, and computer software tracking of customer return activity, all aimed at curbing fraudulent practices.
What CA Laws Apply to Return Fraud?
While there is no specific statute in California for return fraud, other related laws are used to file charges against someone who has allegedly committed return fraud, such as the following:
- Theft. Prosecutors typically charge return fraud under Penal Code 484(a) PC, which includes situations where someone "knowingly and designedly, by any false or fraudulent representation or pretense, defrauds any other person of money, or property."
- Petty Theft. Suppose the merchandise is valued at under $950. In that case, the crime is charged as Penal Code 488 PC petty theft, a misdemeanor punishable by up to 6 months in jail, fines up to $1,000, informal probation, community service, and restitution to the retailer. If you have two prior theft convictions, you may face felony charges that carry a potential prison sentence of up to 3 years.
- Grand Theft. If the merchandise is valued at over $950, the offense becomes Penal Code 487 PC grand theft, a 'wobbler' that can be charged as either a misdemeanor or a felony. A felony conviction carries a maximum prison term of up to 3 years, fines of up to $10,000, formal probation supervision, restitution obligations, and potential civil liability beyond criminal penalties.
- Shoplifting. The crime of shoplifting, as defined under Penal Code 459.5, is entering an open business with the intent to steal merchandise worth $950 or less. Shoplifting is punishable by up to six months in jail and a fine of $1,000.
- Infraction. If the value of the stolen merchandise is less than $50, it could be charged as an infraction under Penal Code 490.1 PC.
Many people accused of return fraud are also charged with stealing goods before returning them. Additionally, some individuals may face additional charges after being accused of returning merchandise as part of an organized retail theft ring, which could involve multiple individuals coordinating to steal and return high-value items.
Defenses to Return Fraud Charges
If you are accused of theft relating to return fraud, our California criminal defense attorneys can use different strategies depending on the specific circumstances of your case.
Perhaps we can argue there was a lack of intent to defraud. The prosecution must prove you acted with specific intent to deceive. If your actions resulted from an honest mistake, confusion about return policies, or a misunderstanding, this could void the required criminal intent.
Perhaps you genuinely believed you were entitled to the refund based on your understanding of the store's return policy or your legitimate purchase of the item. In cases involving surveillance footage or witness identification, showing that the person committing the alleged fraud is not you can result in dismissed charges.
Perhaps we can demonstrate that your return was actually legitimate and that you had proper ownership of the returned merchandise, which directly contradicts the fraud allegations.
Perhaps we can challenge the prosecution's calculation of the total fraud amount, which could potentially reduce charges from grand theft to petty theft, thereby limiting potential penalties. For more information, contact our criminal defense law firm, Cron, Israels & Stark, based in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
