California's Cartwright Act, established in 1907, is a pivotal antitrust law tailored to maintain open and competitive markets within the state.
It functions similarly to federal laws such as the Sherman Act but concentrates on domestic trade practices in California. The Act's goal is to stop anti-competitive behaviors and foster an environment where businesses can innovate, set fair prices, and prioritize consumer interests.
Although the Cartwright Act is a powerful tool for protecting competition in California, its broad scope can lead to businesses and individuals being accused of violations, whether deliberate or accidental.
Understanding the law, what constitutes violations, and the possible penalties is essential for anyone who might face such charges.
What Does BPC 16720 Say?
California Business and Professions Code 16720 says, "A trust is a combination of capital, skill, or acts by two or more persons for any of the following purposes:
(a) To create or carry out restrictions in trade or commerce. (b) To limit or reduce the production or increase the price of merchandise or of any commodity.
(c) To prevent competition in manufacturing, making, transportation, sale, or purchase of merchandise, produce, or any commodity.
(d) To fix at any standard or figure, whereby its price to the public or consumer shall be in any manner controlled or established, any article or commodity of merchandise, produce, or commerce intended for sale, barter, use, or consumption in this State.
(e) To make or enter into or execute or carry out any contracts, obligations, or agreements of any kind or description, by which they do all or any or any combination of any of the following:
(1) Bind themselves not to sell, dispose of, or transport any article or any commodity or any article of trade, use, merchandise, commerce, or consumption below a common standard figure or fixed value.
(2) Agree in any manner to keep the price of such article, commodity, or transportation at a fixed or graduated figure.
(3) Establish or settle the price of any article, commodity, or transportation between them or themselves and others so as directly or indirectly to preclude unrestricted competition among themselves or any purchasers or consumers in the sale or transportation of any such article or commodity.
(4) Agree to pool, combine, or directly or indirectly unite any interests that they may have connected with the sale or transportation of any such article or commodity that its price might in any manner be affected."
Overview of the Cartwright Act
The Cartwright Act is part of the California Business and Professions Code (16720-16770) and addresses agreements between businesses that restrict trade or competition.
Unlike federal antitrust laws, which mainly target monopolistic practices, the Cartwright Act has a wider scope. It governs both horizontal agreements (among competitors) and vertical agreements (between suppliers and distributors) that could harm market competition.
The Act empowers the California Attorney General, district attorneys, and private parties to bring legal action against those alleged to have violated its provisions.
Notably, it allows for both civil damages and criminal penalties, making its consequences potentially severe and underscoring the importance of strict compliance.
What Activities Are Prohibited by the Cartwright Act?
The Cartwright Act explicitly bans various anti-competitive practices. Here are some of the most typical violations it targets:
- Price-Fixing: Price-fixing happens when competitors collude to set prices instead of letting market forces determine them. For example, if two companies agree to uphold a minimum price for a product, it breaches the Act.
- Market Allocation: Market allocation occurs when competitors agree to split territories, customers, or markets to prevent direct competition. For instance, two companies agreeing not to sell within each other's designated regions exemplifies market allocation.
- Bid-Rigging: Bid-rigging is a collusive tactic where competitors secretly cooperate to skew bidding outcomes in their favor. This usually means submitting intentionally inflated or non-competitive bids to guarantee a specific result, often leading to higher prices for the buyer. By controlling the bidding process, the participating parties block genuine competitors from winning the contract, thereby securing their own profits at the cost of market fairness and integrity.
- Tying Arrangements: Tying happens when a company makes a customer buy one product in order to purchase another. This limits consumer options and can give the company an unfair market advantage. For instance, demanding the purchase of an unrelated item, such as software for a popular electronic device, might breach the Act.
- Group Boycotts: This describes agreements between competitors to refuse trading with a specific entity, often aiming to remove that entity from the market. Group boycotts typically target new or smaller firms perceived as threats to larger, established companies.
Enforcement of the Cartwright Act violations
Violations of the Cartwright Act are pursued rigorously to uphold fair competition and may result in civil and criminal charges. The California Attorney General and private parties play critical roles in enforcing the Act. Let's review below:
- Role of the Attorney General: The California Attorney General's office has the authority to investigate and prosecute breaches of the Cartwright Act. It can launch investigations upon receiving complaints or evidence of anti-competitive conduct. If a violation is confirmed, the Attorney General may file a lawsuit to obtain injunctions, impose financial penalties, and pursue corrective measures to re-establish competitive fairness.
- Private Lawsuits: Private parties harmed by anti-competitive practices can also bring lawsuits under the Cartwright Act. These cases may result in monetary damages for the harm suffered. Winning plaintiffs might recover triple the actual damages — known as treble damages — plus attorney fees. This provision helps individuals and businesses enforce fair competition.
- Criminal Charges: Although civil enforcement is more typical, violations of the Cartwright Act can also lead to criminal prosecution. Criminal cases are generally pursued when there is strong evidence of intentional, fraudulent, or egregious anti-competitive conduct, emphasizing the serious repercussions of breaching the Act. Prosecutors might file charges under various state criminal statutes, resulting in misdemeanor or felony charges that can lead to additional fines or imprisonment.
For more details, reach out to our Los Angeles-based California criminal defense attorneys at Cron, Israels & Stark.
Related Content:
