A Civil Investigative Demand (CID) is a crucial tool in non-criminal investigations, serving as a formal request for information and evidence. Federal and state government agencies commonly use it to gather essential data in civil investigations.
In other words, CIDs allow the government to gather any information that it considers relevant to its pre-litigation investigation. CIDs request documents, interrogatory responses (sworn narrative responses), or deposition testimony from witnesses.
CIDs are issued before any formal complaint or lawsuit has been filed. They are also issued when the government is deciding whether to intervene in a qui tam (whistleblower) lawsuit filed under the False Claims Act. The government uses the information obtained from the CIDs to make its decision whether to litigate or decline enforcement.
The government is likely to withhold the full story at first. But what the government must disclose is the subject matter of its investigation in the CID itself. The government investigates many different subject areas with CIDs.
The most common areas of concern are fraud, including healthcare fraud, procurement fraud, and failure to implement adequate cybersecurity measures. The Department of Justice (DOJ) or local United States Attorney's Offices often issue CIDs in fraud investigations.
However, other agencies also have CID authority, including the DOJ Antitrust Division, the Federal Trade Commission, and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. State agencies, such as State Medicaid Fraud Control Units (MFCUs), have the authority to issue CIDs to investigate Medicaid fraud.
The government cannot demand more than what it could request through discovery requests under the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. 31 U.S.C. § 3733(b). If you think the government is demanding too much, you can object and typically negotiate reasonable boundaries.
Key Takeaways
- A Civil Investigative Demand is an administrative subpoena that allows federal government agencies to request extraordinary amounts of information from private entities without going through any formal court approval or procedures.
- CIDs are typically issued in cases involving antitrust issues, consumer protection violations, or allegations of fraud.
- A CID serves as a formal request for documents, testimony, or other evidence to help determine if legal action is necessary.
- A finding of civil liability can result in penalties, and the discovery of evidence of intent can turn into a criminal matter.
- CIDs are typically used during the investigative phase of a case, whether it's you or someone else being investigated.
- Government agencies are not permitted to make overly burdensome, irrelevant, or vague demands.
- Failing to respond to a CID can lead to serious enforcement actions, including fines or additional legal consequences.
- CIDs generally include strict deadlines, often ranging from 20 to 30 days. Missing these deadlines can result in legal repercussions, underscoring the importance of prompt and efficient action when responding to a CID.
- Providing incomplete or false information can lead to further investigation, enforcement actions, or even prosecution.
- You must be honest and transparent in responding to a CID, as the consequences of providing misleading information can be severe.
- It's important to be thorough and cautious when providing information in response to a CID.
- Agencies cannot compel you to produce privileged materials, and you may challenge aspects of the CID.
- You should call for a company-wide "legal hold" on all documentation until the terms of the CID are met.
What Happens After You Turn Over the Information?
After providing the government with the requested information in the CID, several outcomes are possible. You may never hear from them again, indicating you were not the target, or the evidence was insufficient.
Alternatively, the government may inform you of potential enforcement actions or request that you remain available to testify. Being aware of these possibilities can help you prepare for the next steps. Understanding these potential outcomes can help you prepare for the next steps and manage your expectations.
Another possibility is that the government may follow up and inform you that it is considering enforcement action against you. They will typically explain in greater detail why they think you violated the law and why they think the evidence against you is valid.
Typically, however, the government agency is willing to hear your side of the story and any potential defenses or mitigating factors. If you are not able to resolve the matter informally, the government can file a civil lawsuit against you or initiate proceedings before an administrative law judge.
Another possibility is that the government may ask you to remain available as a potential witness against the target of their investigation. This means that you must preserve all relevant documents, including the ones that were not produced to the government but might be related to the subject matter of the investigation.
It is not uncommon to uncover evidence of wrongdoing when searching for documents and information. However, the wrongdoing may or may not be related to what the CID is demanding. If it is not responsive to the CID, you will have to decide whether to self-disclose the information to the government agency that issued the CID.
What Should You Do If You Receive a CID?
Suppose information requested by the CID was inadvertently destroyed. In that case, it can raise significant red flags with investigators and make you a criminally suspect because it gives the appearance of obstruction. You should preserve all potentially relevant materials and ensure nothing is destroyed or altered.
Working with your legal team to compile and deliver the required materials in a well-documented manner demonstrates good faith and helps avoid further complications.
Retaining legal counsel to assist you in preparing your response to the CID and navigating any potential enforcement action that may follow is crucial, as it can provide you with the necessary support and guidance.
It is essential to identify what the CID is demanding and prepare accordingly. Some CIDs are narrow and only request a specific list of business records. Other CIDs are broad and may request all internal email communications on a specific topic.
You also need to issue a litigation hold and identify the individuals within your organization who are likely to have responsive information, and provide some general guidelines. Thorough preparation can empower you to handle the CID effectively.
It will typically require a discussion with your IT professionals to make sure auto-delete settings are disabled for individuals who are likely to have responsive information.
How Can a Federal Defense Lawyer Help You?
All efforts to respond appropriately to a CID must be undertaken with the advice of experienced federal defense attorneys. A federal defense lawyer can assist you with all aspects of your CID response, such as understanding all deadlines and structuring a response plan to ensure that you meet your federal obligations.
Their role is to guide you through the process, ensure compliance, and protect your rights. Their expertise can be invaluable in navigating the complexities of a CID and ensuring a comprehensive and timely response.
If your CID has a deadline to "meet and confer" with agents from the issuing agency, we will schedule the appointment and prepare to meet with them on your behalf. We will meet with you to gather all responsive documents. We will also assess all relevant grounds for challenging the CID.
Often, negotiating with the issuing agency can be the most effective way to limit compliance obligations. If the CID exceeds the issuing agency's authority, we can formally challenge it in federal district court. We will prepare your response and submit it to the issuing agency on your behalf. We will represent you in any follow-up and additional proceedings related to the government's investigation.
A CID does not necessarily mean you are under federal investigation, but it's possible. Agencies have significant experience with these investigations, and seeking guidance from an attorney versed in handling CIDs is crucial.
We can offer critical insights and ensure your rights and interests are protected throughout the response process. Suppose the CID itself suggests you or your company might be under a criminal investigation. In that case, we can also begin taking proactive steps toward creating a defense strategy should it become necessary.
For a free case evaluation, contact Cron, Israels & Stark, located in Los Angeles, California.
Related Content
