A Touhy request, a pivotal tool in the legal process, is a formal, written request for information or testimony from a government agency that is not a party to the lawsuit.
Named after the Supreme Court case United States ex rel. In Touhy v. Ragen, this process is not just a formality, but a necessary step because a regular subpoena alone cannot compel federal employees to produce records or access records without agency approval.
The request should be a meticulously detailed letter outlining the specific information needed, explaining its relevance to the case, and demonstrating that it cannot be obtained elsewhere.
Simply put, to obtain official information, documents, or testimony from a government agency in cases where the government itself is not involved, a formal written request is submitted to the relevant agency rather than a standard subpoena.
The request should specify the case title, the significance of the information or testimony to the case, the specific information or documents sought, and a statement explaining why the information cannot be obtained from other sources.
The agency's legal counsel reviews the request to decide whether to grant it, as the government must authorize the disclosure of its employees' or records' information.
Key Takeaways
- A Touhy request is a formal written request to the government for official information, such as witness testimony and documents.
- A Touhy request is often more effective than a subpoena for obtaining the required information.
- A federal criminal defense attorney might submit a "Touhy request" to obtain essential information for your case.
- A Touhy request is a formal letter sent to a government agency, instead of issuing a subpoena directly.
- A Touhy request may involve seeking documents, testimony from government employees, or access to official information held by a government agency when that agency is not involved in the lawsuit.
- Touhy requests generally ask the requester to show how the information is relevant to the case, confirm that it cannot be obtained from other sources, and supply details about the legal process.
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) requires government employees to notify the U.S. Attorney's Office when they receive a subpoena or similar legal demand. This ensures that the government is aware of and can manage the requests made to its agencies.
What Is a Touhy Request Typically Like?
A Touhy request is submitted as a letter and must include all the information required by the relevant agency regulation. If you also need testimony, include a subpoena that specifies the requested documents and the topics of the testimony.
The letter should contain the necessary details specified by the relevant regulations, as well as information addressing the common grounds the Government might use to oppose the request.
For example, to prevent objections on relevance and burden, it is crucial to explain to the Government why the required information is pertinent and to clarify that it cannot be obtained from any other party or non-party source.
What Details Need to Be Included?
A Touhy request letter should include various types of information, such as the following:
- A detailed list of requests for all documents and information, emphasizing specificity.
- The necessary Touhy regulation for the specific agency, along with a statement that the request complies with it.
- A statement indicating that the United States is not involved in the case and is not expected to join.
- A short overview of the case's factual and procedural background, possibly including a copy of the complaint.
- A statement confirming the requested information's relevance to the case, including a brief explanation.
- A reasoned explanation of why releasing the requested information is justified.
- A declaration of your plan to pay upfront for all expenses related to searching for and producing the information.
- A brief statement clarifying that the information is unavailable elsewhere and that responding won't interfere with official duties.
- A reasonable deadline for submitting the information.
What is the Duration of the Process?
After you submit your Touhy request, the Government can begin searching for the information you need. Since agencies often have to sift through a large amount of data, this process might take some time.
It usually takes several months to obtain the requested documents. Throughout this period, maintaining communication with the agency and collaborating with them is crucial to ensure you receive accurate information within a reasonable timeframe.
Notably, a Touhy request can only be made when a lawsuit is pending and has entered the discovery phase. Unlike a FOIA request, which is generally more straightforward, a Touhy request is more comprehensive, grants access to additional information, and mandates that a lawsuit be active.
Healthcare Fraud Whistleblowers
Healthcare fraud whistleblowers often file Touhy requests with CMS, raising concerns about HIPAA and objections. When making such a request, it's essential to obtain a qualified protective order (QPO).
This helps satisfy HIPAA disclosure requirements and offers CMS written assurances that a court has issued a QPO in the case. A qualified protective order prohibits:
- Parties are prohibited from using or disclosing protected health information outside of litigation.
- Requires that the protected information be either returned or destroyed after the proceedings conclude.
- Guarantees that all protected information is stored under seal and remains inaccessible to the public.
Which Government Agencies are Covered?
Touhy requests are relevant to many federal agencies, each of which has its own regulations on information disclosure. Here are some examples of agencies where a Touhy request could be submitted:
- FBI: A request to the FBI may include seeking investigative reports, evidence, or expert testimony related to a criminal case.
- DEA: The Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) frequently holds records and materials directly related to narcotics investigations, which could be essential in drug-related cases.
- IRS: The IRS's records or testimony may be requested in cases concerning alleged financial crimes or tax fraud.
- ATF: Evidence or testimony from the ATF could be relevant in cases involving firearms, explosives, or violations of controlled substances.
- ICE: Records from agencies such as Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) can be requested in cases involving immigration or cross-border crimes.
- EPA: Records or expertise from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) might be necessary when addressing allegations of environmental violations.
- OIG: When the Office of the Inspector General (OIG) receives a subpoena requiring an SSA-OIG employee to testify or produce records obtained during official duties, it will handle the request as a Touhy request according to 20 C.F.R. Part 403 regulations.
Other federal agencies, such as the Secret Service, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), and even military departments, are likewise governed by versions of Touhy regulations.
When Might a Touhy Request Be Needed?
Your attorney might consider submitting a Touhy request when federal agency records or testimony are crucial for your case. Below are key situations where this could be essential:
- Obtaining Evidence: If federal records can support your case, like digital evidence from the FBI related to alleged online criminal activity, a Touhy request might help obtain exonerating materials or reveal gaps in the prosecution's case.
- Expert Testimony: Federal agencies utilize experts such as IRS auditors, whose testimonies can uncover errors in audits or inaccuracies in the prosecution's findings.
- Challenging the Evidence: If the prosecution depends on reports from agencies, a Touhy request can be used to access raw data or internal documents. This can help your defense identify potential weaknesses or contradictions.
- Chain of Custody Issues: In cases involving physical evidence, submitting a Touhy request to agencies such as the DEA or ATF can clarify the handling process and confirm if proper protocols were followed.
- Government Misconduct: If procedural errors or abuses happen during an investigation, a Touhy request could reveal misconduct that may result in evidence being excluded or charges being dismissed.
Challenges Associated with Touhy Requests
Although Touhy requests can be effective, they are often difficult to implement. Federal agencies tend to be hesitant to disclose information, especially if it might disrupt their operations, breach confidentiality, or interfere with ongoing investigations.
Furthermore, agencies might refuse requests they view as too broad, unrelated, or overly burdensome. A knowledgeable federal criminal defense attorney knows how to formulate a Touhy request accurately. This includes clearly demonstrating the relevance and importance of the requested information for your defense.
Additionally, an attorney can contest an agency's refusal to comply by pursuing court intervention if needed. For more information, contact our federal criminal defense law firm, Cron, Israels & Stark in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
